What older and younger doctors can learn from each other - - ModernMedicine
What older and younger doctors can learn from each other

Source: Medical Economics


Key iconKey Points

  • In one survey of medical residents, 81 percent said adequate call/coverage/personal time was the most or second most important factor when considering employment opportunities.
  • Much of the impetus for greater flexibility in work hours, as well as balancing work and family life, has come from female physicians.
  • Many older doctors believe the reluctance of their younger peers to work longer hours stems, in part, from their differing experiences as residents.

Gordon Cotell, MD, thinks today's younger doctors have it easy compared to what he experienced.


Daniel Berman, MD (left), may be half the age of Gordon Cotell, MD, but the physicians at Doctors of the North Shore, near Chicago, have learned much from one another.
"When I started practice, I was on call two nights a week and every other weekend," recalls the 70-year-old physician, a founding partner of Doctors of the North Shore, a family medicine practice in the Chicago suburb of Morton Grove.

And Cotell should know: These days, the seven-physician practice is made up of a mix of older and younger doctors. In this way, North Shore offers an interesting cross section of perspectives on the differences between older and younger doctors.

"It's just the way things were," says Cotell. "Nobody questioned it. But today, I don't think the doctors want to work as hard. They don't want to take call as much, and want the most benefits for the least work."

On the other hand, Cotell has frequently benefited from younger colleagues' greater technological savvy. "They have often helped me [improve my skills] on the computer and with electronic medical records," he says (see sidebar).

Daniel Berman, MD, 35, joined North Shore three years ago. Call hours were one of the factors that influenced his decision. "I thought it was going to be every sixth weekend, which would have been fine, but it turned out to be every seventh weekend and every Monday, which is even better than I hoped for," he says.

While Berman has helped Cotell and some of the older doctors become more comfortable using computers, the elder doctors in turn have helped him improve the way he relates to patients. "There's definitely a lot of give and take," Berman says.

Cotell's and Berman's experiences typify what many practices go through as they try to accommodate the differing needs and perspectives of older and younger doctors. The challenge is made greater by the relative slowness of the generational shift taking place. According to the American Academy of Family Physicians, the median age of its members has increased from 44.8 in 1996 to 46.7 in 2008. About 55 percent of AAFP's practicing members are age 45 or older.

While generational differences can be a source of conflict, they can also result in better-quality medicine, as doctors of different ages share knowledge and capitalize on each other's strengths. "In practices, each person brings a different skill set and different perspective," says Jennifer Zarate, president and CEO of Professional Medical Staff Associates in Olathe, Kansas. "No one person can know everything, and by exchanging new ideas, everyone wins—especially the patients."


Comments from our Readers
 Posted Mar 10 2009 06:53PM
This is one of the best articles that I have seen on generational changes in the workplace as other articles have often been slanted to make it seem that the younger generation is the dreaded E word, "Entitled". There are numerous studies that prove that more diverse groups create better decision making. I think the mixing of the generations in the field of medicine will only elevate the profession, if people remain open minded. Often assumptions made on both sides can derail these advancements. The younger generation is not lazy, they have been able to observe generations before them and say that is not the path for me (I think this was evident in the recent Presidential election). The older generation is not resistant to learning new things, otherwise they would not have gone into medicine. Remain open, don't assume, and don't judge and we will all be a lot better off.
 Posted Apr 05 2009 02:27PM
I am living this as the Administrator of a 7-physician Family Practice. I have four more mature physician from the "old" school and three younger physicians. One of my physicians will be retiring in a year and I am recruiting another younger physician. Two of my younger physicians, both female, job share via part time schedules to raise their families. I am in the generation between the mature and younger physicians and enjoy working with both schools of thought. There are pros and cons for each generation. The one thing that is obvious is that health care will be changing on so many different levels, with the retirement of older physicians, the dynamics of the provision of health care services will be fundamentally different.
Read More Comments
post a comment
Your email address will NOT be published.
appears with your comment
read our privacy policy
Note: does not support HTML
All comments submitted are subject to review, and may be delayed before posting. We reserve the right not to post comments.

eSamples check closet
eSamples check closet
Practice ToolsPractice Tools
Coding Counselor
Coding Counselor

Simple and accurate ICD-9 code search. Start Here

Patient Education
Patient Education

Print customized patient education handouts. Start Here

Dermatology Diagnosis
Dermatology Diagnosis

Identify skin diseases by age, gender, location. Start Here

AHRQ Clinical Guidelines
AHRQ Clinical Guidelines

Objective findings on medical interventions. Start Here



Source: Medical Economics,
Click here