2009 earnings survey: How do you compare? - As recession gripped America, physician incomes remained stable - ModernMedicine
2009 earnings survey: How do you compare?As recession gripped America, physician incomes remained stable

Source: Medical Economics



Holly Abernethy, MD
A rough year for the U.S. economy had little negative impact on the income of physicians, according to the results of Medical Economics' 2009 Exclusive Survey. As the recession took hold and third-party payers tamped down on reimbursement, physician income scarcely budged from 2007 to 2008.

According to the survey, which was administered in April and May to more than 100,000 office-based MDs and DOs in more than 16 specialties, median earnings for family physicians, internists, general practitioners, pediatricians, and ob/gyns remained roughly the same in 2008 as they were in 2007. Among them, ob/gyns were the top earners, posting a median income of $237,500.

Pediatricians averaged $187,500, followed by FPs, GPs, and internists at $162,500.

Experiencing stable earnings from year to year is better than losing ground, but during tough economic times simply maintaining income often means working harder and looking for innovative ways to boost revenue. Mary Jean Sage, a practice management consultant with the Sage Associates in Pismo Beach, California, views the results in both a positive and negative light.


What primary care doctors earn
"I have had more calls in 2009 than I did in 2008 from physicians who say their patient load has decreased," she says. "Due to the recession, patients have been more selective about going to physicians, and primary care practices are seeing a slowdown in their appointment schedules—not only with regard to new patients, but established patients as well."

Sage notes that there was very little upward change in fee schedule reimbursement from Medicare and other third-party payers in the past year, thus adding to the challenge.

The equation is balanced to a degree, she says, by a rise in practice startups in urban and rural areas that have long experienced physician shortages, particularly in primary care. In general, she believes, "Physicians recognized the recessionary trend early and were judicious about keeping their costs under control as much as possible to avoid a loss of profitability."

Family physician Holly Abernethy practices in Farmington, New Mexico, an area with "a huge primary care physician access problem," as she puts it. She earned about the same in 2008 as she did in 2007, but doing so required working additional hours during the fall and winter months.

Soon, she'll be joining a new practice that offers her a partnership opportunity—though it comes with the tradeoff of lower starting pay.

"A partnership is more important for me and my future," says Abernethy. "The opportunity for more money will come."

Jeffrey B. Milburn, a Colorado Springs consultant with the Medical Group Management Association, says that physicians who earned more or roughly the same in 2007 and 2008 probably did so the old-fashioned way: by reducing expenses and increasing productivity. He adds, however, that the "ripple effect" of increased unemployment—with expiring healthcare benefits and less discretionary income—bodes poorly for physician earnings in 2009.


PHYSICIAN COMPENSATION 2008
Survey respondent Ralph Boling, MD, knows this feeling well. The ob/gyn from Kirksville, Missouri, saw his income decline between 2007 and 2008 despite workweeks of up to 60 hours.

"I still like my work," he says. "I just hate the payments. Medicaid—which pays about 10 percent of billed charges for gynecological services, at best—and other third-party payers make it increasingly difficult to remain profitable."


post a comment
Your email address will NOT be published.
appears with your comment
read our privacy policy
Note: does not support HTML
All comments submitted are subject to review and may be delayed before posting. We reserve the right not to post comments. Comments from patients or members of patients' families seeking medical advice will not be posted.
Comments from our Readers
 Posted 2009-09-29 00:25:38.0
I'm in solo practice. I see 25-30 patients a day. I work 4 1/2 days a week. Full days are from 7:00 till after 5:00.I have cut my overhead as much as humanly possible. My wife is the office manager and she works long days, lots of overtime and does not get time and a half. I personally oversee my biller and collections and beleive the bottom line is very good. I wanted to check on the survey methodology because I wanted to know what is included in the $162,500 reported as the average FP salary. It is not the 42% of primary care docs that make less than $149,999 that make my jaw drop down, but the 68% that make more than $150,000.
 Posted 2009-10-08 10:24:23.0
My wages dropped 7% last year, but remain at the 75th percentile for psychiatry. This is primarily because I am a specialist (see geriatric patients only) and work on an inpatient unit and take call, working one to two weekends per month. My real wages, adjusted for inflation have been stagnant since 2004. I will have to take on more side work and weekend work to maintain my standard of living despite cutting out many routine personal expenses. Still, I would encourage my children to choose medicine (perhaps Radiology, Opthalmology, or Dermatology).
 Posted 2009-10-09 07:24:48.0
I am working more hours and seeing more patients , have cut overhead alot (share the office, etc) still 10% below 2008. This is mainly because of bundling of charges. I used to do Bone Densities and had to sell the machine (at a loss) since there were so few patients that I could still bill for the procedure.
 Posted 2009-10-09 16:33:06.0
Where do you come up with these income numbers? My best friend, an orthopedist, made under $130,000 last yr., her husband, an Internist, made under $50,000, my family practice doc made under $100,000, and I made about $55,000 as an Oculoplastics doc. All of work full-time, typically more than 60 hr./week, and seldom take off more time than is needed for CME's.
 Posted 2009-10-12 17:07:24.0
I make less money than last year but still looking good for a primary care physician (pediatrics+internal med), more than 250K but for the past 5 years I didn't have any vacation. I'd rather get less but have more free time with my family, especially with my 6 year old with ADHD.
Read More Comments
eSamples check closet
eSamples check closet
Practice ToolsPractice Tools
Coding Counselor
Coding Counselor

Simple and accurate ICD-9 code search. Start Here

Patient Education
Patient Education

Print customized patient education handouts. Start Here

Dermatology Diagnosis
Dermatology Diagnosis

Identify skin diseases by age, gender, location. Start Here

AHRQ Clinical Guidelines
AHRQ Clinical Guidelines

Objective findings on medical interventions. Start Here



Source: Medical Economics,
Click here